PDA

View Full Version : ATI's Radeon X800 Texture Filtering Game


Feuerwizard
May 21st, 2004, 11:32 am
http://www.ati.com/home/images/mini_1420_si.jpg

The Recent Revelations about the trilinear filtering techniques ATI has used in its more recent graphics chips, including the X800 series, have been something of a shock. The reason it came as a shock isn't because we've now learned that ATI is using an adaptive algorithm to reduce its graphics workload. Such algorithms make sense, done properly, so they don't harm image quality. Indeed, the essence of graphics is creating an illusion as effectively as possible, and shortcuts are big part of that enterprise.

The shock comes because ATI has consistently touted its own texture filtering techniques as superior to the competition's, talking down the so-called "brilinear" filtering algorithim used by NVIDIA and encouraging use of tools for IQ analysis that don't show the effects of ATI's method. (http://www.techreport.com/etc/2004q2/filtering/index.x?pg=1)

Bruenor
May 21st, 2004, 02:53 pm
So ATI cheats, Nvidia cheats. In the end who really cares anyway?

Terry Penrod
May 21st, 2004, 05:47 pm
.

As a hard core PC gamer who invest a lot of time, money and effort in the hobby, I care very much when any OEMs or software publishers lie about the performance of their products. I don't care if it is a commonly used marketing strategy or not - it is still a dishonest policy intended to fool end users, justify higher prices and to directly harm the competition. It is in a word illegal. It is also immoral and unethical.

Cheers, Terry

.

Bruenor
May 21st, 2004, 05:58 pm
Well, my point was that bpth companies are doing it, whether they are rendering cheats or filtering cheats, we don't have a choice as gamers but to accept them. Nvidia and ATI are the only two real choices for 3d gaming hardware and both are cheating. So, the only real way to take a stand against this is to stop gaming.

In the end for me I don't care who cheats (because they both do), if it looks the ways it's supposed to then I'm happy. The end product is what I care about, not the process the hardware and software go through to make the end product.